The Beekman, A Thompson Hotel

Very unique hotel in the historic Temple Court Building, just a block from City Hall and a few minutes’ walk from the Brooklyn Bridge. Stayed here for 5 nights back in May on a business trip. The building is really the main attraction of this hotel. It was completed in 1883 as one of New York’s first skyscrapers, sat empty for about 15 years, and was beautifully restored before the hotel opened in 2016. Architecture and design are very unique (think Victorian New York with dark wood, velvet and leather everywhere), and the highlight is the beautiful 9-story atrium with its cast iron railings and pyramid skylight, which was designated an official NYC interior landmark in 2024. Rooms are ok. The design is unique, but probably not for me. Noise isolation also not great, so difficult to get a full night of sleep. Service was ok. Pretty typical for NYC, nothing to rave about. Giving 5 stars because of the beautiful, historic building but most likely will stay again at a different hotel next time I’m in NYC.

We had a really great stay at this beautiful hotel that honestly feels like stepping into Europe, with a striking open atrium that sets the tone right away. The bar served excellent drinks and had a cool, moody vibe, and “Le Gratin” was a real highlight—especially during restaurant week with a great lunch. Everyone we interacted with, from valet to the front desk, was warm and kind, which made the experience even better. Our room was spacious with a super comfortable bed, though there was a small issue with the safe that wasn’t fixed before checkout—nothing major for us. We didn’t get to spend as much time on the property as we would’ve liked because of other plans, but the overall stay was still very positive. There were a couple of practical downsides, like the narrow street entrance that can make arrival a bit tricky and a valet setup that doesn’t allow in-and-out privileges despite the cost. Even so, it was a wonderful experience overall, and we’d definitely look forward to coming back with more time to enjoy everything.

We recently booked a family staycation here with our toddler and dog to celebrate my wife's birthday. The physical property is breathtaking and the hard product is top-tier. As a Hyatt Globalist, we were generously upgraded to a pristine Corner Suite. The in-room dining from Temple Court was flawless, and the Guest Relations team executed a beautiful birthday amenity (champagne and cake) perfectly. However, the front desk arrival experience was surprisingly poor for a Thompson property. Despite noting our arrival time, our room wasn't ready when we arrived at 4:40 PM (past standard check-in), which made us late for our evening dinner reservations. Basic elite recognition and proactive communication were entirely absent at the desk. That said, hotel management reached out promptly after our stay, took ownership of the check-in breakdown, and provided excellent service recovery. The property, food, and management are fantastic, but the front-line arrival execution needs tightening. We would gladly return hoping for a smoother check-in.

The Beekman is inside one of the most beautiful buildings in New York. The atrium-style interior is absolutely stunning and made me want to just hang out there and admire the space. The building itself is truly iconic. Unfortunately, my stay left a lot to be desired. When I checked in, there was a wedding taking place, and the organization was absolutely chaotic. I wasn't able to check in until three hours after my scheduled check-in time, and I wasn't offered any type of compensation for the long wait. The way this hotel is run, it seemed like nobody really cares about what's going on. They simply rely on the beauty of the building to lure people in, without the service really mattering. The breakfast was also a sad affair. For such a beautiful space, I expected the food to be on par, but the avocado toast they served was disappointing. For a hotel of this caliber, I expected the breakfast to be more like the Thompson Central Park in terms of quality, but it left a lot to be desired. The rooms were slightly dated, which I understand comes with the territory of staying in a historic building. That said, I've stayed in other hotels housed in historic buildings where it felt like much more care had been put into decorating and maintaining the rooms. Overall, it's a shame that such a beautiful property is so poorly managed. It feels like they simply rely on the stunning interior to keep their rooms booked, when the service should be just as memorable as the building itself.